Lucasfilm isn’t dumb enough to make an Indiana Jones 6, right?
After Dial of Destiny lost over $130 million, would Lucasfilm really make Indiana Jones 6? The short answer is no, not the way you’re picturing. But there’s a reboot rumor that’s both smarter and riskier. Here’s what’s actually being planned, and whether it’s a terrible idea.
After Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny cracked the whip and then face-planted at the box office, one question keeps circling: would Lucasfilm really be foolish enough to make an Indiana Jones 6?
The answer is more interesting than a simple yes or no. Because the movie you’re probably dreading isn’t the one that might actually happen. Here’s the real state of the franchise, and whether Disney is about to make a huge mistake.
First, remember how badly Dial of Destiny bombed
Let’s set the stage, because the numbers explain the hesitation.
Dial of Destiny (2023), meant to be Harrison Ford‘s grand finale as Indy, was one of the biggest money-losers in recent Disney history. The film cost a reported $295 million or more to produce, making it one of the most expensive movies ever, and grossed only about $384 million worldwide. Sounds fine, until you learn it needed somewhere around $477 to $600 million just to break even.
The estimated loss landed around $134 to $143 million.
It wasn’t just the money. The film earned a franchise-low 71% on Rotten Tomatoes and left audiences cold. Director James Mangold later gave the honest diagnosis: fans simply didn’t want to watch their hero as an old man. “You have a wonderful, brilliant actor who’s in his eighties,” he told Deadline. “His audience... doesn’t want to confront their hero at that age. It hurt.”
So, is “Indiana Jones 6” happening? Not really
Here’s the key thing everyone gets wrong.
The version of “Indy 6” most people imagine, Harrison Ford strapping on the fedora one more time, is essentially dead. Ford is 83, he’s officially retired from the role, and Lucasfilm has been crystal clear it will not recast him. There’s no secret plan to drag an 84-year-old Ford back for another round. On that front, no, they’re not that dumb.
Outgoing Lucasfilm boss Kathleen Kennedy basically said as much on her way out the door. Her money quote: “I don’t think Indy will ever be done, but I don’t think anybody is interested right now in exploring it.”
Translation: the character isn’t buried forever, but nobody’s rushing a sequel into production. So the straight “Indiana Jones 6” everyone’s bracing for? It’s not on the table.
The real rumor: a full reboot
Here’s what’s actually being whispered, and it’s a different beast entirely.
The persistent rumor, from the scoop site DisInsider, isn’t about a sequel at all. It’s that Lucasfilm is quietly exploring a full reboot of Indiana Jones, with a brand-new actor, a fresh timeline, and a possible tease at the 2026 D23 Expo. Disney clearly still believes the fedora and whip have value, even if the last outing flopped.
But pump the brakes hard. This is early-stage rumor, nothing is greenlit or official, and insider Jeff Sneider threw cold water on the timeline, saying any reboot is “many, many years away.” Lucasfilm’s plate is already full trying to rebuild Star Wars, which keeps shoving Indy to the back burner. So this is a “maybe someday,” not a “coming soon.”
Would a reboot be dumb? Here’s the honest case
Here’s where it gets genuinely debatable, because there are real arguments both ways.
The case that it’s a terrible idea: Recasting an icon is a minefield, and Lucasfilm knows it firsthand. Kennedy openly pointed to the painful lesson of Solo: A Star Wars Story, where recasting a young Han Solo flopped and, in her words, put the new actor “in an impossible situation.” Indiana Jones is Harrison Ford in most people’s minds. Ask anyone to picture Indy, and they see Ford’s face. Trying to replace that is asking for a fan revolt, and a repeat of the Solo disaster.
The case that it could work: On the other hand, the character himself is bulletproof, an all-time icon built on a template (globe-trotting, artifact-hunting adventure) that doesn’t depend on one actor. And there’s real, recent proof the brand still sells: the 2024 video game Indiana Jones and the Great Circle was a genuine hit, showing audiences still love Indy when the material’s good. Plenty of franchises, James Bond being the obvious one, have thrived by recasting the lead. A great script and the right actor could absolutely relaunch this.
So, are they dumb enough?
To directly answer the question: no, Lucasfilm is not dumb enough to rush out a Ford-less Indiana Jones 6 as a quick cash grab. That movie isn’t happening, Ford’s done, they won’t recast him, and there’s zero urgency. On the thing everyone fears, they’re playing it smart by not doing it.
The reboot is the real question, and the smart read is that it’s neither inevitable nor imminent. If Lucasfilm eventually does it right, years from now, with a killer script and an actor who can carry the whip, it could work, the character is that strong. If they do it lazily, chasing brand recognition without the care the icon demands, they’ll Solo it and learn the exact same lesson twice. The difference between a smart reboot and a dumb one isn’t whether they make it. It’s how.
For now, Indy’s resting. And honestly, after Dial of Destiny, a long rest is probably the smartest move Lucasfilm could make.
Because the only thing worse than retiring a legend is dragging him back before you’ve figured out how to do it right.
Want More Clownfish TV?
This article was brought to you in part by The Reefers of more.clownfishtv.com. Free subscribers get articles like this one in their inbox. Paid subscribers get the full Clownfish TV podcast feed, livestreams, and members-only episodes that never hit YouTube.
D/REZZED is part of Clownfish TV. For more news, views, and rants on gaming, tech, and pop culture, watch @ClownfishTV on YouTube and find the podcast on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and iHeart.
Article compiled and edited by Derek Gibbs (entertainment editor) and the Clownfish TV newsroom.
Hat Tips:
Deadline and ScreenRant (January 2026), verified for Kathleen Kennedy’s comments on the franchise’s future (the “I don’t think Indy will ever be done, but I don’t think anybody is interested right now in exploring it” quote, the confirmation that Ford will not be recast, her Lucasfilm departure with Dave Filoni and Lynwen Brennan as successors, and the Solo: A Star Wars Story “impossible situation” recasting lesson)
Forbes and Wikipedia (2023-2026), verified for the Dial of Destiny numbers (the ~$295 million-plus budget, ~$384 million worldwide gross, ~$477-600 million break-even estimate, ~$134-143 million loss, the 71% Rotten Tomatoes franchise low, and its 2023 release as Ford’s final film), and James Mangold’s Deadline comments about audiences not wanting to see Ford’s Indy age
DisInsider (via JoBlo and IMDb) and Jeff Sneider (2025-2026), verified for the reported full-reboot rumor (a new actor, fresh timeline, and possible D23 2026 tease, all reported as rumor rather than confirmed), Sneider’s “many, many years away” caution, and the 2024 video game Indiana Jones and the Great Circle demonstrating the character’s continued commercial appeal